Loading...
You are here:  Home  >  Industry  >  Current Article

The Musician’s Silent Epidemic

By   /   May 26, 2010  /   9 Comments

There’s an epidemic going on that no one wants to talk about. Lots of people in our business are hurting, and computer work is the main culprit.

There’s an epidemic going on that no one wants to talk about. Lots of people in our business are hurting, and computer work is the main culprit.

One composer I know says every bone and joint in her body hurts all the time. She is saving up for a hydraulic lifter for her keyboard and computer workstation, so she can vary her position, working standing up as well as seated. Another I know has intense shoulder pain, and can’t raise his arm above shoulder level. He doesn’t want his clients to know, because he’s afraid they will think he can’t do the work.

The first person I ever heard of who injured his hands trying to become a better musician was the composer Robert Schumann. In trying to develop increased finger independence at the piano, he famously immobilized his fourth fingers with a length of string and ended up crippling his hands. It’s said that this motivated him to turn to composition.

Unfortunately, he wasn’t the last person that ever hurt himself creating music. It’s estimated that as many as a third of symphony and studio musicians will at some point in their career deal with pain or injuries to the hands. It’s very common to deny or conceal these problems, for fear of getting a reputation for being disabled and losing work.

In today’s world the job of composer is not a haven from such injuries. Intensive computer use, combined with the pressures of huge workloads and deadlines, can lead to serious problems if one isn’t careful. Many fail to recognize the problem until it is too late.

DO I HAVE CARPAL TUNNEL SYNDROME?

I recently discussed this situation with Laura Stewart, president of Wellspring Therapy of Glendale. In the 20 years she has been an occupational therapist and certified hand therapist, she has gained a reputation as one of the foremost authorities on treatment and recovery from injuries of the hand. She stresses that the absolute most important thing about dealing with this sort of injury is to prevent it from happening in the first place; we’ll get to that in a moment.

But what if you’re already feeling a twinge, how can you find out more about it? The news media, in simplifying things for mass consumption, have led us to believe that anything that goes wrong with the hands must be carpal tunnel syndrome. But in reality, there are a number of different things that can go wrong with your hands, wrists, arms and shoulders. Most common are carpal tunnel syndrome, tendonitis, and osteoarthritis. Here’s a simple way to tell the difference:

Carpal tunnel syndrome: Between the bones of your wrist, there are several tiny tunnels through which tendons and nerves must pass. Repetition of a motion with hands or fingers can cause swelling of the tendons that make the fingers move, constricting the nerves that share the carpal tunnel. Symptoms of this include numbness, tingling, pain that resembles a burning feeling in the hands, and eventual weakness of hands and fingers.

If this is your problem, you may feel numbness and tingling on the inside half of your hand, that is the thumb, index, middle, and the inside half of your ring finger. Why? Because the nerves that lead to those figures go through the carpal tunnel. Nerves that go to other parts of the hand go through other tunnels in the wrist.

Tendinitis: Tendinitis is inflammation of the tendons in the hand, wrist, and forearm that attach muscles to the bones. Symptoms are primarily pain and decrease in movement; this problem seldom causes numbness.

Osteoarthritis: This form of arthritis (not to be confused with rheumatoid arthritis, which is not included in this discussion) is often associated with aging, but can happen to people of any age. It is caused by the deterioration of the cartilage between the bones, the pad surfaces that cushion their intersections. Of the three types of injury, this type can most easily be diagnosed using X-rays.

STEERING CLEAR OF DANGER

Repetitive motion injuries can be serious and very painful, and can even threaten your career. There are ways to avoid these problems, or mitigate them if you’re already having some trouble, but it often can be difficult. It often takes very substantial changes in work habits, physical fitness, and even attitudes towards the work you do — real life changes.

High pressure and tight deadlines aren’t the only reason one can develop this sort of problem. Composers and other creative people are often very highly motivated, even to the point of being obsessive. It’s a rush and a thrill when a good piece of music takes shape, and one can lose track of the hours fine-tuning and tweaking the sounds with the mouse and keyboard. Later you finally come up for air and then, “Ouch!” The pain and other symptoms are often delayed.

The body wasn’t designed to do the same small repetitive tasks for an extended time, and the equipment isn’t always designed to help the body in the best way. Here are few tips on how to work smart and prevent injuries; they may look familiar, but are worth thinking about again:

Good ergonomics and posture: You must be able to reach your computer keyboard and mouse without straining. A good keyboard workstation should have a computer keyboard tray that is adjustable in its height and angle. As you sit up straight and reach for the keys, your elbows should not be bent at an angle tighter than 90 degrees. That is, make sure your chair is high enough and your keyboard is low enough that you’re not reaching up to the keyboard or mouse. Try to always hold your wrists straight and even, in a neutral position, never arched nor sunk down nor twisted sideways. Try to relax your shoulders; tension can make them rise up toward your ears. And make sure your screen is high enough that you don’t have to hunch or slump — a good rule of thumb: sit up straight in front of your screen; the top one-fourth of its area should be at about eye level and three-fourths below.

Reality check: What do we do about a workstation that also has a MIDI controller keyboard? For good playing technique the MIDI keys need to be at a proper height as well; a grand piano usually has its key tops at approximately 27- 28 in. Some people are more comfortable with a tray for the computer keyboard that is down low underneath the piano keys, perhaps on a sliding track, and some place the computer keyboard on top of the MIDI keys. It may also work to have the computer keyboard and mouse off to one side. Some trial and error may be necessary. But watch out for extremes — I know one composer who had his Macintosh keyboard down at the very far left-hand end of the 88-key controller, and the track ball to the right at the opposite end. His work position had him splayed out like he was on a cross, a real recipe for back, shoulder, and hand pain. Ow!

It’s also important to get a good adjustable chair that is the right size for you. Make sure it has good lumbar (lower back) support, and if there are armrests they should be adjusted low enough that they don’t make you hunch your shoulders or get in the way when you play music. Even though various wrist pads are popular, most physical therapist strongly advise that you don’t rest your wrists or arms while you type or work the mouse; it’s important that the large muscles of the arms and shoulders are used to support the hands and fingers, and that you have some flexibility to move your body as you work.

Keep fit. A sedentary lifestyle can lead you to getting hurt much more easily. Think of yourself as a “hand athlete” — if you did that much continual work with your legs, such as running, you would understand the need for good fitness throughout your body. Therapists often recommend cardiovascular exercise and weight training (although if you are already hurting don’t just start lifting weights without guidance!). And, as with any athletic workout, a start with a warm-up and stretches, including your hands, is always wise.

Keep your tools sharp. Just as it takes many more pounds of force to cut up a chicken with a dull knife than with a sharp one, computer tools that are stiff or worn out can make your work harder than it needs to be. The tiny movements that you do over and over with your hands should be made as easy as possible for them. Little bits add up! I recently sat down at a composer’s workstation and found the track ball to be so rough and stiff that it practically took two hands to move it. A good-quality trackball should glide with only a feather-light touch. Sometimes they need cleaning or lubrication or just replacing. Your fingers will thank you.

Take breaks and break up your tasks. When we get obsessed, or on a deadline, it’s easy to lose track of time. Taking regular breaks, even if it’s just to get up and stretch and walk around the room for five minutes, is essential. And if you’ve got more than one job on your to-do list, it’s better to do a little bit of one and then a little bit of the next rather than to power through on just one task.

TOOLS THAT CAN HELP

There are lots of “ergonomic” keyboards and other accessories out there. Different people get good results from different things. Here are a few accessories that many find useful:

Kensington Turbo Mouse: This is a large (2″) trackball. Its broad size helps you keep your hand in more of a flat position, which can help avoid pain. Also, the four or more buttons (depending upon the model) can be programmed to common actions such as click-hold (drag), double-click, etc. (Avoid the wireless model.) Many people find that a traditional mouse can cause stress and tension in their arms and shoulders, due to the fact that a lot of work you do dragging things around on the screen involves holding down the button and so your arm is continually tensed. Instead, you can momentarily click a click-hold button, then lightly roll the ball to make the edit or other drag, and then click again to release. I’m often surprised by people who don’t bother to program the buttons and get accustomed to them — give it a try; once you get the hang of it you will find that it helps a lot.

Kinesis programmable USB foot switch (Kinesis-Ergo.com): The 3 foot pedals can be programmed to duplicate any button on your mouse or keyboard. If your hands are tired of all the clicking this can help. (It can also come in handy as a “record” foot switch for punching yourself in and out.)

Voice-recognition software: The best one I have found for Macintosh is Dictate from MacSpeech/Nuance. It’s not perfect but there’s not much else to choose from. (This article was written using it.) If you use a Windows machine, Dragon Naturally-Speaking is said to be quite good. Unfortunately these are only useful for writing tasks such as word-processing and e-mail; they’re not much help in most music software.

FOR MORE INFORMATION

The book to get: This may well be the most important part of this article. If you’re having pain or other problems with your hands, or just want to learn more so that you can avoid such problems, an essential book is “Repetitive Strain Injury: A Computer User’s Guide” by Emil Pascarelli, M.D., and Deborah Quilter. This contains an absolute wealth of information about hand physiology, ergonomics, managing pain, and how to deal with medical help if you need it.

Doctors and physical therapists: Not all physicians are aware of or trained in repetitive hand injuries, and you may have to work to get your insurance to cover it. In the Los Angeles area, there are physical therapy clinics that specialize in this type of rehabilitation; some research will help you find one that might work for you.

RSI support groups: Many cities have support groups that meet regularly, in public libraries or other places, and offer informed speakers, suggested resources, and folks to commiserate with. An internet search may find resources in your community.


LES BROCKMANN is a Los Angeles-based recording engineer and score mixer with over 20 years experience in television music, from NORTHERN EXPOSURE (CBS) to KING OF THE HILL (Fox), feature films including the award-winning documentary GHOSTS OF ABU GHRAIB (HBO) and the cult howler TRAIL OF THE SCREAMING FOREHEAD (Larry Blamire, dir.), and video games UNCHARTED 1 & 2 (Sony/Naughty Dog). You can find his SCOREcast bio (and links to his other sites) here.

    Print       Email

About the author

Les Brockmann is a Los Angeles-based recording engineer and score mixer with over 20 years experience in television music, from Northern Exposure (CBS) to King of the Hill (Fox), feature films including the award-winning documentary Ghosts of Abu Ghraib (HBO) and the cult howler Trail of the Screaming Forehead (Larry Blamire, dir.), and video games Uncharted 1 & 2 (Sony/Naughty Dog). You can read more about Les' career and all of his projects at his official website, LesBrockmann.com.

  • Yaiza Varona

    Excellent article, thank you so much for your insight. Very helpful indeed!

  • http://lesbrockmann.com/ lesbrockmann

    By the way, I neglected to mention, the majority of this article was previously published in “The Score”, the magazine of the Society of Composers and Lyricists; used with permission.

  • http://www.mitchellwestmoreland.com Mitchell Westmoreland

    Excellent article. Thanks Les. I’ve noticed for me that most aches and pains are caused by a combination of overuse and using to many muscles to do a job that only requires a few. i.e. Why are my shoulders, neck, upper arm, forearm flexed when I’m just typing, or clicking a mouse? So, a few things that have helped me (besides the obvious proper ergonomic set-up of my work area):
    • Yoga and meditation. It really helps me to bring awareness to what my body is doing in the moment. I tend to notice when and where I’m ‘over-flexing’ and then I can relax.
    • I learned to use my mouse with my non-dominant hand. It’s not as hard as it may sound. It took a bit of practice, but once I learned, it took loads of stress off of the other side of my body. I alternate every few weeks or so.
    • Finally, check out the Alexander technique. If you’re not familiar with it, it’s basically a technique to maintain awareness of your body’s muscles and an attempt to properly use only the ones that should be employed at any one time. Ok, that wasn’t the best definition, but, if you’re interested there’s plenty of info online.

  • Chris

    This is an important issue. In additions to your comments, personally I have found a few things especially helpful to keep wrist/hand/arm pain at bay.

    1) Set up keyboard shortcuts for certain repetitive tasks-undo, stop, start (obvious ones) but whatever commands you use repeatedly make sure to set up a keyboard shortcut.
    2) Use a chair with arms that supports your mouse hand/arm. This can get in the way for playing the keyboard depending on your preferences but I find it a necessity.
    3) Get a three or 4 button mouse and assign your most repetitive task to the one or two assignable buttons. For me I always assign the thumb button to “close window” (command w). It is probably the most frequent action people do using a computer and it saves a lot of mouse movement over the course of a day.
    4) Make sure your monitor, chair and keyboard height are appropriate for you. There is no one size fits all here since everyone is a different height and some people may be taller or shorter through the mid section and need to adjust their work stations accordingly. You must experiment with this. When you work for a week with no arm or neck strain, that's a good sign. Working through a day with neck stiffness or back stiffness is usually a sign you don't have these set up properly for your body type.

    On a side note, I personally have not found trackballs to be very useful/ergonomic but as you say it's personal preference and worth a shot for people having problems using the mouse.

  • http://lesbrockmann.com/ lesbrockmann

    It's not like you're swinging a 5 pound hammer for 10 hours a day, but it's just as real in the way mouse and keyboard work can cause damage: small strains repeated hundreds or thousands of times. I agree about the mouse, it's the gripping and the downward pressure–your hand never gets the chance to relax.

    It's worse if you're a keyboard pounder or bring a heavy touch to the machine. It's hard to train yourself to not react to the stress of deadlines, or the excitement of the music (hopefully) by hitting it hard.

    I always liked the trackball because if you're careful you can touch it really lightly. (The newest generation from Kensington with optical sensors rather than rollers are much lighter to the touch.) You can set a button to be “drag”. But for me it works best in combination with the foot pedal; I hardly ever touch the mouse or trackball buttons.

    Everybody's situation is different. Learn what helps, and do your best to stick with it. Sometimes you have to really completely retrain the way you touch things; there are therapists out there who specialize in this sort of bodywork training.

    Hang in there! Take it seriously before it's too late, and you'll have a better chance of making your career last a lifetime.

  • http://www.adrianelliscomposer.com/AdriansBlog Adrian Ellis

    I've really disliked trackballs when I've had to use them. I find the strain is worse on the wrist, but maybe I am doing it wrong. What I'm waiting for are those holo interfaces like in Minority Report… naww, scratch that – WYTIWYG – What You Think Is What You Get!!

  • http://deaneogden.com Deane Ogden

    AWESOME information, Les. Kudos to you for bringing up such an important and often overlooked point of concern.

    In reference to Lee's question below about Trackballs, I will vouch for Les' endorsement of the Kensington Turbo Mouse. I think the one I have is the TM Pro model, but they are essentially the same, maybe plus a button or two.

    I was a “mouse” guy for years until someone turned me onto the Turbo Mouse. The motion of having to pick up my wrist every time I drag something across my arrange page or mixer was affecting me more than I realized, and only after I switched over to the Turbo Mouse did I notice how much. A mouse, for me, is a KILLER on my wrists and the tension created by having to “clasp” my hand around one for, sometimes, 16 hours straight was destroying my hands. I highly recommend a Turbo Mouse or some other type of trackball device. Once you get used to it (took me about two days before I was spinning around like a pro), you'll never go back.

    And Lee—Not sure about “Missile Command”, but I could roast your ass at “Centipede”! :o P

  • lhsanders

    Hugely important article, Les—thank you for this. I'm curious, though, how many people here in the community like trackballs. I've found them to be incredibly divisive: on the occasions when the subject has come up (pretty rare, admittedly, but we *are* geeks for this stuff, right? it does happen!), people tend to love 'em or hate 'em.

    For those of us of a certain age, I think it's down to how much Missile Command we played as kids. :-)

    Anyway, trackballs: love 'em? hate 'em? Indifferent?

  • http://www.adrianelliscomposer.com/AdriansBlog Adrian Ellis

    That's great information Les! Man, some of those horror stories are kind of scary – definitely warrants a second look at the studio setup. For me, mouse position is the killer, including repetitive click/drag.

    In general, what we do is pretty bad for your health! Getting regular exercise is so important, not only for the body, but also for the mind and general sense of well being. As a type 1 diabetic, this is not an option for me; I make time for this with only rare exceptions. It can be small things, spread out – just as they say it's healthier to eat small snacks over the course of the day, why not have little mini work-outs? If you got out of the chair, stretched properly, and did maybe 10 or 15 minutes of light aerobic excercise, tai chi, or sit ups and push ups, etc… it would add up. Do 10 sit ups every hour and a half – by the end of an 8 hour workday you'd have racked up 50 sit ups or more.

    It also helps clear the mind. If you are in 'lock-down' mode, set an alarm. Given the dangers of damage, which could totally shut down operations, taking a bit of time out to stay healthy makes sense.

    Some other ergo helpers:
    - A Wacom pen tablet, which is great for drawing in automation. The smaller models have really come down in price.
    - Become a hot-keys power user. It's actually possible to do most actions in a sequencer without even touching the mouse!

  • Articles by Date

    May 2010
    S M T W T F S
    « Apr   Jun »
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    3031  
  • The Archives

You might also like...

free-work

What Are You Worth?

Read More →